Soil compaction and organic matter removal effects on soil properties and tree growth in the Interior Douglas-fir zone of southern British Columbia

Abstract

Silviculture systems and associated forest harvesting practices that affect the level of soil compaction and organic matter retained on a site will cause changes to soil properties and processes that may affect the growth of planted trees. We present results for soil conditions and tree growth after 15 years for 6 Long-term Soil Productivity Study (LTSP) installations in 2 distinct regions of the Interior Douglas-fir (IDF) biogeoclimatic zone in southern British Columbia (BC). In a 3 × 3 factorial design, three levels of compaction and organic matter removal were replicated in two distinct IDF regions that varied in parent material, but with similar climates. Each treatment was then split and planted with two different species, Douglas-fir and lodgepole pine. In each region, three unique sites (block), all within a radius of 50 km from one other, were installed with the same combination of treatment and species for a total of six replicates, three in each of two regions. Across IDF regions, tree heights on calcareous soils in the Rocky Mountains of south-eastern BC were 36% lower for Douglas-fir and 23% lower for lodgepole pine than on more acidic soils on the Thompson Plateau. There were varying differences across treatments in soil and foliar nutrient concentrations between IDF regions, primarily from regional parent material differences. However, nutrient deficiencies were apparent in both regions and may have limited growth, especially on the more calcareous sites. Increases to soil bulk density (27%) 1 year after compaction did not impact tree survival, height at Year-15, or chemical properties in foliar tissue or soil. Fewer growing season frost events and increased soil water availability during the seedling establishment period was a likely reason for a 25% increase in Douglas-fir survival at Year-15 with the whole tree + forest floor removal (OM3) treatment. However, whole tree + forest floor removal (OM3) also produced a 13–19% reduction in soil N, S, K, and mineralizable N when compared to both stem-only (OM1) and whole tree (OM2) harvesting treatments that kept the forest floor intact. Effects on forest productivity from soil compaction after 15 years appear to be overshadowed by the more prominent effect of organic matter removal treatments during stand establishment and early growth. Future work at these installations focusing on nutrient budget, forest health, and ecosystem carbon stock differences across treatments will provide valuable insight into silviculture and harvesting practices for different species and regions in the dry forests of southern BC.