Site-directed transformants with E407K substitution in Bcmdl1 possesses different fitness from field anilinopyrimidine resistant isolates with E407K mutation in Botrytis cinerea

Abstract

Botrytis cinerea is the causal agent of devastating disease gray mold on numerous crops worldwide. To control gray mold, anilinopyrimidine (AP) fungicides have been widely applied since the 1990s. However, the development of resistance in B. cinerea brought a new challenge to this disease control. Due to the unknown mode of action, the mechanism of AP resistance is still ambiguous. In our previous study, mutation E407K in Bcmdl1 was identified to be associated with AP resistance. Since this mutation is the major mechanism of AP resistance in our cases, it is essential to investigate the fitness of E407K strains before designing anti-resistance management strategies. Besides using field-resistant isolates with the E407K mutation, strains with E407K substitution obtained by site-directed mutagenesis were also used to estimate the specific effect of this mutation or substitution on fitness. The fitness of E407K strains were evaluated by determining mycelial growth, sporulation, conidial germination, virulence, acid production, osmotic and oxidative sensitivity, and sclerotial production and viability. Field resistant isolates with E407K mutation produced fewer sclerotia on intermediate medium (IM) but more conidia on PDA when compared with sensitive isolates, whereas site-directed transformants with E407K substitution did not show any fitness costs. The competitive ability of E407K strains was also evaluated on apple fruit using conidial mixtures at three initial ratios of resistant and sensitive isolates at 1:9, 1:1, and 9:1, respectively. Similar with fitness, impaired competitive ability was observed in field resistant isolates but not site-directed transformants at all initial ratios tested. These results indicated that field strains associated with AP resistance suffer a fitness penalty not linked directly to the E407K substitution in Bcmdl1.