Single-Plane Versus Synchronous Biplane Ultrasound Imaging During Vascular Access Procedures: Which Is Better and How Can We Improve?

Abstract

Highlights Biplane ultrasound imaging reduces need for probe manipulation during procedure. Providers note clinical benefit of biplane ultrasound imaging for vascular access. Biplane disadvantages include probe size, imaging quality, size of the screen. Thorough didactic and practical education is essential for biplane success. Abstract Background: Use of ultrasound guidance for vascular access procedures is commonplace in inpatient and outpatient care settings. Standard ultrasound probes offer the operator a single-plane view, necessitating rotation of probe to attain dual complimentary views. This mechanical probe rotation increases technical difficulty of ultrasound use. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the rate of cannulation success and efficiency of a synchronous biplane ultrasound mode in ultrasound-guided arterial line placement as compared with a standard single-view ultrasound mode in the operating room setting. Methods: Patients scheduled for elective surgery in which a radial arterial catheter would be used for hemodynamic monitoring were approached for consent to this study. Patients were randomized to either undergo placement with single-plane view versus synchronous biplane view; outcomes were recorded. Providers were provided preprocedural ultrasound education as well as the option of a short hands-on experience; their level of experience was noted. Results: Placement time of a peripheral arterial catheter was longer and required more attempts to be successful using synchronous biplane imaging as compared with single-plane imaging across providers of all skill/experience levels. Subjectively, providers noted the benefit of synchronous biplane imaging in vascular access; however, disadvantages including probe size, quality of imaging, and size of the screen were noted. Discussion: Thorough education regarding the use and functionality of biplane synchronous imaging in vascular access is essential. Additional guided-practice time with experienced operators could also be helpful to overcome the challenges observed in this study.