Shrub effects on the decomposition microenvironment and changes in litter quality have opposing effects on litter decomposition

Abstract

Increasing abundance of tall deciduous shrubs has been shown to affect tundra soil properties, which may further affect carbon and nitrogen cycling in these soils, including through effects on litter decomposition. These tall deciduous shrubs produce a higher quantity of litter, and also a different quality of litter, than tundra species in non-shrub dominated tundra, both of which may affect community-wide decomposition rates. We examined how presence of tall deciduous shrubs, including resulting increases in litter quantity, affects litter decomposition through effects on both the decomposition environment and on litter composition. In a factorial experiment, we modified the decomposition environment by manipulating both the abundance of tall deciduous shrubs (present/absent) and their litter (absent, natural, and doubled). In each environment we decomposed litter of the tall deciduous shrub, Betula glandulosa and two other dominant species in our study area; Salix reticulata, a dwarf deciduous shrub, and Carex consimilis, a graminoid. We report that while tall Betula shrub presence reduced decomposition rates, decomposition was not affected by manipulations of litter quantity. Although litter decomposed slower under deciduous shrubs, B. glandulosa litter decomposed faster than the litter of the other dominant tundra plant species. However, the reduction in decomposition rates due to tall deciduous shrub presence and higher decomposition rates of B. glandulosa litter in comparison to other plant species were of the same magnitude and these opposing effects may result in little to no change of shrub encroachment on litter decomposition rate overall.