Short communication: Comparing the microbiota diversity from the core, middle part and rind of six Spanish commercial goat cheeses

Abstract

The cheese core has a lower oxygen saturation and salinity and a higher acidity than the rind, but there is controversy about the incidence of such factors on the magnitude of microbial diversity. The goal of the current work was to investigate the existence of differences in α-diversity between the core, middle part, and rind of six Spanish commercial cheeses through a sequencing approach. To this end, we have collected rind, middle part, and core samples from fresh (H and M), soft semi-ripened (C and P), hard semi-ripened (B) and semi-hard aged (G) goat cheeses. After purifying deoxyribonucleic acid from these 18 samples, the V3-V4 ultravariable region of the 16S rRNA gene was sequenced. The analysis of microbial composition revealed that lactic acid bacteria from the genera Lactococcus, Lactobacillus, Streptococcus, and Leuconostoc are predominant in all six goat cheeses. Furthermore, we identified several psychrophilic taxa often associated with the post-pasteurization contamination of refrigerated milk. Comparison of three α-diversity estimators (Chao1, Shannon and Faith's phylogenetic diversity indices) of microbiota in the core, middle part, and rind of all six goat cheeses did not reveal substantial differences, being only significant (at the nominal level) the comparison of rind vs middle part for the Shannon index (P-value = 0.031). Moreover, the construction of a dendrogram based on Aitchison distances revealed that cheese samples cluster according to their manufacturing characteristics, with a clear distinction between fresh vs semi-ripened or aged cheeses. We conclude that the magnitude of microbial α-diversity in the cheese core is similar to that in the rind despite their different physicochemical attributes. This result could be because physicochemical differences between cheese compartments are often attenuated during cheese ripening.