Sexual dimorphism and polymorphism in a Callovian Phlycticeras (Ammonoidea) assemblage of Kutch, India

Abstract

An assemblage of Phlycticeras Hyatt from a precisely dated zone of Middle Callovian in Kutch, India has been analyzed. Systematic study reveals that this sample can be divided into two size groups. The larger set shows different adult modifications leading to ornamental polymorphism. Polymorphs are very similar, if not identical, to different chronospecies of Europe, which range between Middle to Upper Callovian. They are grouped under well-known Phlycticeras polygonium (Zieten). The group of smaller specimens on the other hand, strongly resembles a species, which has been previously described as Phlycticeras schaumburgi (Waagen) from the younger Upper Callovian horizons in Kutch. It has a peculiar ‘rooster’–like septicarinate keel in the venter near adult aperture. Phlycticeras-Oecoptychius have been considered as a possible dimorphic pair since long, but here shown to have many inconsistencies to support these views. Instead, sexual dimorphism is explored within Phlycticeras and P. polygonium-P. schaumburgi is proposed as possible antidimorphs. A similar association is found in different stratigraphic assemblages of Europe. Interestingly these two morphs show parallel evolutionary changes within the Phlycticeras genus.