Septal penetration correction in I-131 imaging following thyroid cancer treatment

Abstract

Whole body gamma camera images acquired after I-131 treatment for thyroid cancer can suffer from collimator septal penetration artefacts because of the high energy of the gamma photons. This results in the appearance of ‘spoke’ artefacts, emanating from regions of high activity concentration, caused by the non-isotropic attenuation of the collimator. Deconvolution has the potential to reduce such artefacts, by taking into account the non-Gaussian point-spread-function (PSF) of the system. A Richardson–Lucy deconvolution algorithm, with and without prior scatter-correction was tested as a method of reducing septal penetration in planar gamma camera images. Phantom images (hot spheres within a warm background) were acquired and deconvolution using a measured PSF was applied. The results were evaluated through region-of-interest and line profile analysis to determine the success of artefact reduction and the optimal number of deconvolution iterations and damping parameter (λ). Without scatter-correction, the optimal results were obtained with 15 iterations and λ = 0.01, with the counts in the spokes reduced to 20% of the original value, indicating a substantial decrease in their prominence. When a triple-energy-window scatter-correction was applied prior to deconvolution, the optimal results were obtained with six iterations and λ = 0.02, which reduced the spoke counts to 3% of the original value. The prior application of scatter-correction therefore produced the best results, with a marked change in the appearance of the images. The optimal settings were then applied to six patient datasets, to demonstrate its utility in the clinical setting. In all datasets, spoke artefacts were substantially reduced after the application of scatter-correction and deconvolution, with the mean spoke count being reduced to 10% of the original value. This indicates that deconvolution is a promising technique for septal penetration artefact reduction that could potentially improve the diagnostic accuracy of I-131 imaging.Novelty and significanceThis work has demonstrated that scatter correction combined with deconvolution can be used to substantially reduce the appearance of septal penetration artefacts in I-131 phantom and patient gamma camera planar images, enable improved visualisation of the I-131 distribution. Deconvolution with symmetric PSF has previously been used to reduce artefacts in gamma camera images however this work details the novel use of an asymmetric PSF to remove the angularly dependent septal penetration artefacts.