Sensing the State: The Importance of Making the Researcher’s Citizen-State Relationship Explicit within Qualitative Research

Abstract

In this article, I challenge the tendency towards underreported engagement with one’s own positionality vis-à-vis the state and note that qualitative manuscripts offer a unique opportunity to engage in liberatory practices by articulating this specific aspect of positionality on the page. To provide empirical evidence of the value of identifying and reckoning with the scholar’s relationship with the state, I use an autoethnographic approach to articulate the explanatory power of considering of my own state relationship within the research analysis and writing processes. I show that early findings from a qualitative research endeavor led me to view citizen coproduction practices that targeted homeless individuals as overly deterministic rather than distinctively malicious and tied to systems of state violence. In writing the manuscript that was relevant to this research endeavor, I engaged with my positionality vis-à-vis the state directly within the document which enhanced the validity of my final findings. As the qualitative research process is particularly suited for this liberatory practice, I conclude with some loose guidance for other researchers seeking out ways to identify their own relationship with the state and place it within the manuscript.