Seismic fragility analysis of buckling-restrained brace-strengthened reinforced concrete frames using a performance-based plastic design method

Abstract

An easily-operated performance-based plastic design (PBPD) method for buckling-restrained braced (BRB) reinforced concrete (RC) moment frames is adopted in this research to strengthen existing moment frames by BRBs. The appropriate range of the story base shear ratio p (i.e., the ratio of the base shear resisted by the BRBs to that of the total system) is suggested through a seismic fragility analysis. With an earthquake ground motion set of thirty far-field records, the seismic fragility analysis and risk assessment of an 8-story RC moment frame structure and its strengthened structures with BRBs are reported in this article, in which the fragility curves for different limit states and the corresponding annual exceedance probability are calculated. The applicability of 16 ground motion intensity measures (IMs) in the fragility analysis of the structure before and after strengthening under three damage limit states is further reviewed. As indicated by the fragility analyses, a higher seismic resistance capacity can be obtained for the strengthened structure when the ratio p varies between 0.5 and 0.8. The seismic performance of the structures strengthened using the PBPD method can increase steadily till the advent of the preset target ultimate drift limit, after which the improvement efficiency decreases. The IM Sa,gm(Ti) that considers both effects of softened period and higher mode has a better performance in each limit state of the structure both before and after strengthening.