Salton Sea days of future past: Modeling impacts of alternative water transfer scenarios on fish and bird population dynamics

Abstract

The Colorado River Quantification Settlement Agreement (QSA) of 2003 gives urgency for studying the environmental consequences of the cessation of mitigation water transfers to the Salton Sea. The Salton Sea Stochastic Simulation Model (S4M) is a spatially-driven, stochastic, simulation model representing water flow, i.e., water volume and quantity of Total Dissolved Solids and Phosphorus, in the Lower Colorado River Basin, Mexicali Valley, and the Salton Sea Basin. The S4M is formulated as a compartment model based on difference equations with a daily time step using STELLA® v8.0. The model was developed, evaluated, and applied to simulate the potential effects on the population dynamics, i.e., natality, mortality, emigration, and immigration, of selected fish and avian species at the Salton Sea under two different scenarios: 1) QSA water transfers to Sea end after 2017 and 2) QSA water transfers continue at 2017 levels. Oneway ANOVAs were performed for the water quantity, water quality, and selected variables involving the fish and bird population dynamics under the two water transfer scenarios. Results indicate that if cessation of the QSA water transfers after 2017 occurs, then fish and bird populations will be significantly (P<0.05) and negatively impacted by year 2024, compared to continuing the QSA water transfers. Further, if no restoration action is taken in stabilizing the Sea elevation and reducing salinity but continuing QSA water transfers (at 2017 levels), i.e., scenario 2; results indicate that Salton Sea avian and fish population dynamics will be negatively impacted, although somewhat delayed.