Rural telepsychiatry is economically unsupportable: the Concorde crashes in a cornfield.

Abstract

T the use of communication technologies to offer psychiatric services, has become a topic of great interest as a means of overcoming the effects of the shortage of psychiatrists in rural areas (1–4). The idea of using telecommunication in psychiatry is not new. In fact, examples can be found as far back as 1959, and the topic has been well reviewed (1,4–6). Although the technology has improved to the point of providing adequate audiovisual interactions, the cost-effectiveness of these interactions remains unassessed. Clearly, technological feasibility does not eliminate the need for economic practicality. Before relying on telepsychiatry as a solution to inadequate psychiatric services in rural areas, we need to consider economic variables such as the cost of the equipment, charges for maintaining connections, the volume of use, and reimbursement. We also need to consider its impact on existing systems of care into which it would be introduced. We studied the feasibility of implementing a telepsychiatry system to link psychiatrists at Michigan State University with patients at a community mental health center (CMHC) in rural Michigan. The target county we studied has a population of 58,000 and is approximately 75 miles from the university. The county is poor and demographically similar to many rural counties and is designated by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services as an area with a shortage of mental health professionals. Many people lack transportation. Based on our feasibility study, this column examines the economics of setting up a telepsychiatry system through which care can be provided to a rural area. Moreover, we estimated the cost of delivering one type of patient care (medication management) via this system. The purpose of the paper is not to provide a technological discussion of designing a system. Rather, we offer an analysis of economic issues and systems problems encountered in setting up a very basic telepsychiatry installation at the low end of the cost range.