Abstract
Predictions in ungauged basins have been a major challenge in hydrologic sciences, and there is still much work needed to achieve robust and reliable predictions for such basins. Here, we propose and test a novel approach for predicting runoff from poorly gauged basins using a minimum complex model calibrated with isotope data alone (i.e., without observed discharge data). The model is composed of two water-stores (soil water and groundwater) and considers their connectivity to runoff in terms of both water and isotope budgets. In a meso-scale basin in which riverbed deformations frequently occur, making automatic observation of river discharge difficult, we measured hydrogen and oxygen isotope composition (δ2H and δ18O) of precipitation and river water twice-weekly for one year. Runoff predicted by the model agreed well with that observed monthly or bimonthly. Monte Carlo simulation revealed a strong coherence between model performance in isotope simulation and runoff prediction, demonstrating that the use of isotopes as dynamic proxies of calibration targets helps reliably constrain model parameters. Our results indicate that this approach can serve as a powerful tool for prediction of runoff hydrographs, particularly for basins in which the stage-discharge relationship is highly variable.
Highlights
River gauging has been conducted since the foundation of human civilization, as indicated by the Nilometer in ancient Egypt (Dooge, 2004)
Our results indicate that this approach can serve as a powerful tool for prediction of runoff hydrographs, for basins in which the stage-discharge relationship is highly variable
Sensitivity of NSE in runoff prediction (NSEr) to kC changes was greater around the best kC value for isotope simulation, suggesting the importance of local optimization for improving runoff prediction. These results suggest that isotope simulation is highly sensitive to base flow, but less sensitive to soil water storage associated with quick flow
Summary
River gauging (i.e., measuring water level and, by inference, flow) has been conducted since the foundation of human civilization, as indicated by the Nilometer in ancient Egypt (Dooge, 2004). The Prediction in Ungauged Basins (PUB) initiative (Sivapalan et al, 2003) launched by the International Association of Hydrological Sciences has resulted in considerable advances in hydrology (Blöschl et al., 2013), much of this success has been in gauged rather than in ungauged basins; there is still a long way to go to achieve robust and reliable predictions without river gauging (Hrachowitz et al, 2013). Prediction of runoff hydrographs has been made using a wide spectrum of rainfall-runoff models (Beven, 2012). These models all must be calibrated by comparing predicted runoff with observed one (Wagener et al, 2004).
Published Version (Free)
Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have