Road salt is more toxic to wood frog embryos from polluted ponds

Abstract

Organisms that rely on aquatic habitats in roaded landscapes face a growing array of consequences from pollution, especially due to freshwater salinization. Critically, these consequences can vary from population to population depending on exposure histories and evolutionary responses. Prior studies using transplant and common garden experiments have found that aquatic-stage wood frogs (Rana sylvatica) from roadside populations are less fit in the wild and more sensitive to road salt than their counterparts from woodland populations away from roads. While this pattern is consistent with local maladaptation, unresolved insights into the timing and duration of these effects leave open the possibility that negative outcomes are countered during development. Here, we asked whether the survival disadvantage of roadside wood frogs is stage-specific, and whether this disadvantage reverses before metamorphosis. We used a common garden road salt exposure experiment and a field-based reciprocal transplant experiment to examine differences in survival across life-history stage and with respect to population type. In each experimental context, roadside embryos showed a survival disadvantage relative to woodland embryos, and this disadvantage was not reversed prior to metamorphosis. We also found that salt exposure delayed metamorphosis more strongly for roadside than woodland populations. Together, these results suggest that local maladaptation in aquatic-stage wood frogs is driven by embryonic sensitivity to salt and that roadside populations are further compromised by delayed developmental rates. Future studies should consider which embryonic traits fail to adapt to salt toxicity, and how those traits might correlate with terrestrial trait variation.