Rethinking Routine Surgical Excision for all Radial Sclerosing Lesions of the Breast

Abstract

IntroductionThe need for routine surgical excision of a radial sclerosing lesions (RSL) of the breast identified on percutaneous biopsy remains controversial, as contemporary upgrade rates are lower than historically cited. Materials and methodsA prospectively-maintained database of high-risk breast biopsies undergoing multidisciplinary review at a single institution was queried to identify cases of RSL from 2/2015 to 11/2020. Demographic, radiologic, and pathologic variables were summarized using frequencies and analyzed in association with RSL excision status using mixed-effects logistic regression or Fisher's exact tests. Results217 RSL were identified, diagnosed at a mean age of 57 y. The median imaging size was 1.3 cm and the majority had estimated >50% of the target removed by core needle biopsy. 32.3% underwent surgical excision of the RSL biopsy site and 2/70 (2.9%) upgraded to ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) on final surgical pathology. Upgrade was significantly higher for atypical RSL (P = 0.02). None of the RSL (n = 60) without atypia who had undergone excision were upgraded. For those omitting surgical excision, there was no subsequent breast cancer diagnosis at the RSL site over a mean follow-up of 23 mo. ConclusionsSurgical excision may be omitted for RSL without atypia as this group has 0% risk of upgrade after multidisciplinary review.