Reply on RC2

Abstract

Given its abundant coal mining activities, the Upper Silesian Coal Basin (USCB) in southern Poland is one of the largest sources for anthropogenic methane (CH4) emissions in Europe. Here, we report on CH4 emission estimates for coal mine ventilation facilities in the USCB. Our estimates are driven by pair-wise upwind-downwind observations of the column-average dry-air mole fractions of CH4 (XCH4) by a network of four portable, ground-based, sun-viewing Fourier Transform Spectrometers of the type EM27/SUN operated during the CoMet campaign in May/June 2018. The EM27/SUN were deployed in the four cardinal directions around the USCB in approx. 50 km distance to the center of the basin. We report on six case studies for which we inferred emissions by evaluating the mismatch between the observed downwind enhancements and simulations based on trajectory calculations releasing particles out of the ventilation shafts using the Lagrangian particle dispersion model FLEXPART. The latter was driven by wind fields calculated by WRF (Weather Research and Forecasting model) under assimilation of vertical wind profile measurements of three co-deployed wind lidars. For emission estimation, we use a Phillips-Tikhonov regularization scheme with the L-curve criterion. Diagnosed by the averaging kernels, we find that, depending on the catchment area of the downwind measurements, our ad-hoc network can resolve individual facilities or groups of ventilation facilities but that inspecting the averaging kernels is essential to detected correlated estimates. Generally, our instantaneous emission estimates range between 80 and 133 kt CH4 a−1 for the south-eastern part of the USCB and between 414 and 790 kt CH4 a−1 for various larger parts of the basin, suggesting higher emissions than expected from the annual emissions reported by the E-PRTR (European Pollutant Release and Transfer Register). Uncertainties range between 23 and 36 % dominated by the error contribution from uncertain wind fields.