Repeated measures analysis of projectile penetration in porcine legs as a function of storage condition

Abstract

Listen

Translate article

Buried blast explosions create small projectiles which can become lodged in the tissue of personnel as far away as hundreds of meters. Without appropriate treatment, these lodged projectiles can become a source of infection and prolonged injury to soldiers in modern combat. Human cadavers can be used as surrogates for living humans for ballistic penetration testing, but human cadavers are frozen during transport and storage. The process of freezing and thawing the tissue before testing may change the biomechanical properties of the tissue. The goal of the current study was to understand penetration threshold differences between fresh, refrigerated, and frozen tissue and investigate factors that may contribute to these differences.A custom-built pneumatic launcher was used to accelerate 3/16″ stainless steel ball bearings toward porcine legs that were either tested fresh, following refrigerated storage, or following frozen storage. A generalized linear mixed model, accounting for within-animal dependence, owing to repeated observations, was found to be the most appropriate for these data and was used for analysis. The “generalized” model accommodated non-continuous observations, provided a straight-forward way to implement the repeated measures, and provided a risk estimate for projectile penetration.Both storage condition (p = 0.48) and leg (p = 0.07) were shown to be not significant and the confidence intervals for those variables were overlapping. As all covariates were found to be non-significant, a single model containing all impacts was used to develop a V50, or velocity at which 50% of impacts are expected to penetrate. From this model, 50% probability of penetration occurs at 137.3 m/s with 95% confidence intervals at 132.0 and 144.0 m/s.In this study, the fresh legs and previously frozen legs allowed penetration at similar velocities indicating that previously frozen legs were acceptable surrogates for fresh legs. This study only compared the penetration threshold in tissues that had been stored in differing conditions. To truly study penetration, more conditions will need to be studied including the effects of projectile mass and material, the effects of projectile shape, and the effects of clothing or protective layers on penetration threshold.