Regional streamflow prediction in northwest Spain: A comparative analysis of regionalisation schemes

Abstract

Study Region: The present study was conducted in 24 watersheds located in the region of Galicia, in the northwest of Spain, covering an extension of approximately 13,000 km2.Study focus: This study is focused on the application and evaluation of different schemes for streamflow Prediction in Ungauged Basins (PUB). The MHIA model (Spanish acronym for Modelo HIdrológico Agregado), is first used to reproduce the observed time series of discharge in several gauged basins. Then, six different regionalisation schemes are applied to transfer the hydrological model parameters to ungauged catchments. For that purpose, we explore and compare two physical similarity, two spatial proximity and two regression-based regionalisation schemes. Output averaging (also known as ensemble modelling) as well as parameter averaging implementations of the physical similarity and spatial proximity methods are analysed.New hydrological insights: The most efficient methods are those based on output averaging, with acceptable success rates (SR) in 88% of the cases. On the other hand, the parameter averaging-based methods have the lowest SR. The methods based on spatial proximity output averaging provide the best performance when the receptor basin has a sufficient number of nearby donor basins. On the other hand, the methods based on physical similarity output averaging show a better performance in areas where there is a low density of donor catchments. The regression-based methods showed the lowest performance in all cases. The existence of correlations between the performance of the regionalisation schemes and the area of the receptor catchments was observed, with higher performances in large basins than in small basins.