Reduced vegetation integrity in selectively logged Atlantic rainforest affects bird diversity: Higher taxonomic and functional diversity, but increased niche overlap

Abstract

Although selectively logged tropical forests have high bird species richness, it is known that their species composition is substantially changed when compared with intact forests. Thus, we need to improve the understanding on how functional trait diversity of birds is affected in this habitat type in order to support the development of more effective conservation actions to maintain functional roles and community stability. Here, we evaluate traits responses to variations in forest vegetation integrity and how the pattern of niche occupancy is affected by this increase in species richness. We then evaluated the effects of vegetation integrity in the Atlantic rainforest on range of trait space occupied, niche packing, and trait composition in local bird communities. We also evaluate the mechanisms driving niche expansion and packing using null models. Our results show that trait composition changes in communities: (1) lower vegetation integrity increases foraging in understory and consumption of grains and ectothermic vertebrates by birds; (2) higher vegetation integrity drives higher and wider beaks and increase foraging for invertebrates in canopy. We also found that lower vegetation integrity not only is associated with the increase of species richness, but also with both expansion and packing of niche space occupied by the community. However, only niche packing had predominantly smaller values than expected by chance, indicating a strong effect of environmental filters on niche occupancy density. Although bird assemblages in more intact vegetations have lower species richness, they have greater functional distance between bird species suggesting greater stability, with a low probability of local extinctions due to a lower intensity of interspecific competition. This demonstrates that isolated assessments of species richness are potentially illusory and can lead to unsuccessful conservation measures, such as proposing selective logging in primary forests based on the supposed benefit of increased bird species richness in vegetations less intact. Furthermore, the functional composition tends to change with changes in vegetation integrity degree, thus altering the functional role provided by communities. Consequently, forests with high vegetation integrity status should be maintained, despite the lower species richness.