Redox-dependent Ti stable isotope fractionation on the Moon: implications for current lunar magma ocean models

Abstract

In terrestrial magmas titanium is predominantly tetravalent (Ti4+), in contrast, lunar magmas are more reduced (IW-1) and hence approximately 10% of their bulk Ti content is trivalent (Ti3+). Changes in oxidation state and coordination number are both important parameters that can serve to drive Ti stable isotope fractionation. As such, mineral–mineral and mineral-melt Ti stable isotope fractionation factors determined for terrestrial samples may not be appropriate for lunar samples that formed under more reducing conditions. To address this issue, several experiments were carried out in gas mixing furnaces over a range of fO2 (air to IW-1) to determine Ti stable isotope fractionation factors for minerals, such as ilmenite, clinopyroxene and rutile that are highly abundant on the Moon. Results show that the extent of Ti stable isotope fractionation significantly increases with decreasing fO2. For example, the isotopic difference between ilmenite and residual melt (Δ49Tiilmenite-melt) is resolvably lower by ~ 0.44 ‰ from terrestrial-like FMQ-0.5 to lunar-like IW-1 at an intermediate precision of ± 0.003 ‰ (95% c.i. OL–Ti). This confirms that fractionation factors determined for terrestrial conditions are indeed not applicable to lunar settings. Our new fractionation factors for ilmenite, clinopyroxene and silicate melt are mostly consistent with those previously determined by ab initio modelling based on density-functional theory. Using our new experimental data in conjunction with previously published high-precision HFSE data and Ti stable isotope data of lunar basalts, we modelled the solidification of the Lunar Magma Ocean (LMO). The model for LMO solidification included fractionation of Ti stable isotopes not only by Ti-oxides, but also by typical lunar silicate minerals as pyroxene or olivine. The resulting δ49Ti for urKREEP and ilmenite-bearing cumulates are within error of previous estimates, but also indicate that ilmenite-bearing cumulates must have contained around 15% ilmenite.