Problems and Suggestions Related to Soil Classification as Presented in Introduction to Physical Geology Textbooks

Abstract

Complex concepts and ideas are often presented to introductory level students in a simplified form for educational purposes. This simplification sometimes requires that the “whole truth” not be presented. However, the simplified material should be current and factual to the extent that future lessons that build on the introductory material will expand on the originally presented material rather than contradicting it. The presentation of soil classification in many current introductory physical geology textbooks is over 35 years out of date. In addition, the way soil classification terminology is used would be questionable even if it were still current. Individuals teaching introductory geology courses that include sections on soils and the authors of textbooks using incorrect classification terminology should obtain current references on soil classification and correct these deficiencies.