Probing the timing of the onset of the modern-style plate tectonic regime in Earth's history

Abstract

Following the Earth's formation about 4.6 Ga, its initial basaltic outer layer underwent differentiation, generating the oldest continental crust. However, how and when this differentiation took place and what processes led to the formation of early silicic continental crust are controversial topics, which are rooted in a bigger question of when modern-style plate tectonics started operating in Earth's history. In general, there is a well-accepted consensus that the Earth transitioned from single lid (squishy, stagnant, and/or sluggish lid?) to plate tectonics at some point, largely as a result of the establishment of the first subduction zone(s). Members of the geoscience community are divided in answering the question of the timing of the onset of plate tectonics, as reflected in the four perspective papers by different international research teams here. Using different proxies and datasets, the proposed models range from the Late Archean to Paleoproterozoic, and Neoproterozoic for the beginning of a plate tectonic convective regime. Another interpretation states that we do not know when plate tectonics might have started based on the extant observations and data. Although the beginning of plate tectonics is still a subject of debate, most researchers agree on the definition of plate tectonics as a globally networked system of laterally moving rigid plates riding on the aesthenosphere and mantle convection cells, which facilitated recycling of the top boundary layer through time. Testing the proposed models and concepts in these perspective papers with new data, observations and geodynamic modelling efforts will be critical to better understanding the Earth's thermal history and evolution since 4.4 Ga.