Prevalence of Progressive Collapsing Foot Deformity in Hallux Valgus Patients

Abstract

Category: Bunion; Midfoot/Forefoot Introduction/Purpose: Hallux valgus (HV) and progressive collapsing foot deformity (PCFD) are very common foot and ankle conditions in the adult population. Both could potentially disrupt the tripod construct of the foot which leads to chronic pain and arthritis. Several procedures were described to address HV deformity depending on deformity characteristics. PCFD could alter the management plan for HV if they occur simultaneously. The aim of this study was to detect the prevalence of PCFD in HV patients and study the frequency of individual PCFD classes. Methods: In this retrospective IRB approved study, patients > 18 years old who were evaluated for symptomatic hallux valgus and had a weight bearing computed tomography (WBCT) imaging were included. Patients were considered for further analysis if they have a hallux valgus angle (HVA) > 15° or inter-metatarsal angle (IMA) > 9°. All relevant demographic data were extracted. Two fellowship trained foot and ankle orthopaedic surgeon measured the following parameters: foot and ankle offset (FAO%) (Class A), talo-navicular coverage angle (TNCA) (Class B), Meary’s angle (Class C) and middle facet subluxation (MFS%) (Class D). Cases that showed FAO% > 4.6% and MFS% > 28.7% were diagnosed as PCFD. The prevalence of PCFD classes (A,B,C and D) was calculated using threshold values for its respective radiographic marker. Descriptive statistics were performed. Results: Thirty-four cases were included. 16 cases were females (46.06%) and 16 (46.06%) were right side. The average age was 52.51 years (SD ± 17.75), the average BMI was 30.14 (SD ± 7.15). The average HVA was 26.82 (SD ± 9.98) and the average IMA was 15.41 (SD ± 3.53). 13 patients (38.24%) had MFS% and FAO% above the threshold values. The average FAO was 4.75% (SD ± 4.92) and the average MFS was 29.17% (SD ± 15.89). Prevalence of Class A (FAO%) was 20 (58.82%), Class B (TNCA) was 12 (35.29%), Class C (Meary’s angle) was 15 (44.12%) and Class D (MFS%) was 16 (47.06%). Conclusion: Progressive collapsing foot deformity is prevalent in the hallux valgus population (38.24%). Class C which indicates medial column instability was prevalent in 44.12% of the cases. Given this high prevalence of PCFD, we believe that in addition to the classic hallux valgus parameters, PCFD classes evaluation could favor a surgical approach over another such as first tarsometatarsal joint procedures over isolated distal first metatarsal procedures to correct the HV deformity and simultaneously halt PCFD progression.