Predictability of temperaments and negative experiences on higher-order symptom-based subtypes of depression

Abstract

BackgroundThe identification of subtypes of depression based on higher-order symptoms of emotional, thought, and behavioral dysfunction will broaden understanding of the heterogeneity in depression. Furthermore, exploring the ability of temperaments and negative experiences to predict each subtype is an effective way of facilitating treatment decisions. MethodsParticipants were 417 patients diagnosed with depressive disorder at the psychiatry department of a major medical hospital in Seoul, Korea. A latent profile analysis was performed based on three higher-order scales of the MMPI-2-RF: Emotional/Internalizing Dysfunction, Thought Dysfunction, and Behavioral/Externalizing Dysfunction. Four temperament dimensions were assessed by the Temperament and Character Inventory-Revised-Short, and negative experiences including recent negative life events, number of lifetime traumatic events, and severity of maltreatment, were used as covariates in a multinomial regression analysis. ResultsFour classes were obtained from the latent profile analysis: a “severe mood class” (39.8%), a “moderate mood class” (37.4%), a “mild mood class” (11.3%), and a “severe mood/thought class” (11.5%). Among temperament dimensions, high harm avoidance and low persistence significantly predicted more severe mood classes. Low reward dependence, number of lifetime traumatic events, and severity of maltreatment in negative experiences were significant predictors of the severe mood/thought class. LimitationsThis study could not explain the more detailed heterogeneity within depression because of over-inclusiveness of the higher-order scales. ConclusionsThis study identified three latent classes that differed in emotional severity and one other class with thought problems. The distinct dimensions of temperament and different types of negative experiences predicted the identified subtypes.