Positional accuracy assessment of historical Google Earth imagery in Lagos State, Nigeria

Abstract

The horizontal accuracy of historical Google Earth (GE) images at four epochs between the years 2000 and 2018, and the vertical accuracy of its elevation data within Lagos State, in Nigeria, are respectively evaluated by comparison with a very high–resolution digital orthomosaic and comparison with 558 ground control points. Two readily available 30-m digital elevation models (DEMs) — the Shuttle Radar Topography Mission (SRTM) v3.0 and the Advanced Land Observing Satellite World 3D (AW3D) DEM v2.1. — were also compared with GE elevations. A novel approach for assessing the space–time variations in the magnitude and direction of errors in GE imagery is presented. For horizontal accuracy, the root mean square errors (RMSEs) are as follows — year 2000 (16.9 m), year 2008 (16.4 m), year 2012 (6.1 m) and year 2018 (6.1 m). The most recent GE imagery (year 2018) had the least horizontal error while year 2000 had the largest horizontal error. The horizontal shift was skewed towards the western and north-western directions, indicative of systematic error. In terms of the vertical accuracy, GE elevation data had the lowest accuracy and highest RMSE of 6.21 m followed by AW3D with an RMSE of 4.39 m and SRTM with an RMSE of 3.68 m.