Porosity localizing instability in a compacting porous layer in a pure shear flow and the evolution of porosity band wavelength

Abstract

A porosity localizing instability occurs in compacting porous media that are subjected to shear if the viscosity of the solid matrix decreases with porosity ( Stevenson, 1989). This instability may have significant consequences for melt transport in regions of partial melt in the mantle and may significantly modify the effective viscosity of the asthenosphere ( Kohlstedt and Holtzman, 2009). Most analyses of this instability have been carried out assuming an imposed simple shear flow (e.g., Spiegelman, 2003; Katz et al., 2006; Butler, 2009). Pure shear can be realized in laboratory experiments and studying the instability in a pure shear flow allows us to test the generality of some of the results derived for simple shear and the flow pattern for pure shear more easily separates the effects of deformation from rotation. Pure shear flows may approximate flows near the tops of mantle plumes near earth's surface and in magma chambers. In this study, we present linear theory and nonlinear numerical model results for a porosity and strain-rate weakening compacting porous layer subjected to pure shear and we investigate the effects of buoyancy-induced oscillations. The linear theory and numerical model will be shown to be in excellent agreement. We will show that melt bands grow at the same angles to the direction of maximum compression as in simple shear and that buoyancy-induced oscillations do not significantly inhibit the porosity localizing instability. In a pure shear flow, bands parallel to the direction of maximum compression increase exponentially in wavelength with time. However, buoyancy-induced oscillations are shown to inhibit this increase in wavelength. In a simple shear flow, bands increase in wavelength when they are in the orientation for growth of the porosity localizing instability. Because the amplitude spectrum is always dominated by bands in this orientation, band wavelengths increase with time throughout simple shear simulations until the wavelength becomes similar to one compaction length. Once the wavelength becomes similar to one compaction length, the growth of the amplitude of the band slows and shorter wavelength bands that are increasing in amplitude at a greater rate take over. This may provide a mechanism to explain the experimental observation that band spacing is controlled by the compaction length ( Kohlstedt and Holtzman, 2009).