Perspectives on Organic Development

Abstract

The ‘mutual enrichment’ between the two forms of the Roman Rite — as called for by Pope Benedict XVI in Summorum Pontificum — can begin without any formal changes to either form of the Rite. But in the future, it may be hoped that the forms of the Roman Rite will be influenced by one another (and by other historical uses). The need for restoration in the postconciliar liturgy is clear, e.g. the non-traditional character of the Liturgia Horarum, the Holy Week ceremonies, and the proper chants and orations of the Mass. Yet the pre-conciliar books also need some revision, in line with the modest reforms actually proposed by the Second Vatican Council. Possible developments might include a wider use of the vernacular, a somewhat expanded cycle of scriptural pericopes, an infusion of prayers and prefaces taken from the ancient sacramentaries, or an adaptation of the chanted Propers for smaller choirs. It will be advisable in plotting any reforms to look beyond the ‘Curial-Tridentine horizon’, to some of the ea...