Performance evaluation of six digital mammography systems

Abstract

The strong advance in digital mammography as a tool for breast cancer screening requires that the new systems be characterized. Quality control protocols describe the methodology to evaluate systems performance. Detective quantum efficiency (DQE) is the most suitable parameter for describing the imaging performance of an X-ray imaging device. The objective of this study was to characterize in terms of DQE six digital mammography systems, at different detector air kerma (DAK) levels for a variety of beam qualities. A Carestream EHR-M3 CR detector, a small field digital mammography system Siemens Opdima, and full field digital mammography systems Planmed Clarity, GE Essential, GE Pristina and GE Crystal Nova were characterized using the European Guidelines protocol. Modulation transfer function (MTF), normalized noise power spectrum (NNPS) and DQE were determined, for an extended detector air kerma range. Attenuated beam qualities (obtained by adding 2 mm Al to the corresponding beam qualities) used were 28 kV with anode/filter combination Mo/Mo for the EHR-M3, Opdima, Essential and Pristina systems; 28 kV W/Ag for the Clarity; 28 kV W/Rh for the Crystal Nova; 28 kV Mo/Rh for the EHR-M3; and 34 kV Rh/Ag for the Pristina. Two groups were identified in MTF analysis, and the group composed of Clarity, Opdima and Essential presented the highest MTF values. In NNPS analysis, three main groups were identified, in which the systems Crystal Nova and Essential presented lower and higher NNPS, respectively. Crystal Nova system also exhibited higher DQE values for low spatial frequencies, while Opdima and Clarity presented higher DQE values for medium to high spatial frequency. Agreement with data from literature indicates that the systems evaluated are operating under typical conditions. Evidence of improvement in detectors performance was found.