Performance comparison of HONNs and FFNNs in GPS and INS integration for vehicular navigation

Abstract

In present days, real time navigation depends on Kalman filter to fuse data from Global Positioning System (GPS) and Inertial Navigation System (INS). But there exist drawbacks like long design time, requirement of prior knowledge in fusing data from GPS and INS using Kalman Filter. In order to overcome the drawbacks of Kalman filter, GPS and INS integration are done using Artificial Neural Networks (ANN) like FFNNs. But still there exists certain drawbacks like less accuracy in FFNNs for GPS and INS data integration. Therefore, this paper introduces Higher Order Neural Networks (HONNs) approach for INS and GPS data integration to overcome the drawback. A higher order feed forward neural network architecture with optimum number of nodes is used. In the given architectures, the replacement of summation at each node by multiplication results in more powerful mapping, because of its capability of processing higher-order information from training data. Performance comparison of HONNs with FFNNs shows that the proposed architecture provides satisfactory results in terms of error rate and number of epochs. The HONNs like Multiplicative Neural Network (MNN) module and Sigma-Pi-ANN module and Traditional Feed Forward Neural Networks(FFNNs) like Radial Basis Function Neural Network (RBF) module and Back propagation Neural Network (BPN) module are trained to predict the INS position error and provide accurate position of the moving aircrafts. Sigma-Pi ANN is found to be the best in terms of accuracy, number of epochs and execution time among the two HONNs.