Performance analysis of data fusion methods for radar and IRST 3D target tracking

Abstract

Data fusion algorithms are inevitable in improving the accuracy and reliability of radar target tracking. Considering the shortcomings of target tracking in Cartesian coordinates, all the fusion process are carried out in spherical coordinate system. To fuse data from bidimensional radar and Infrared Search and Track (IRST), five data fusion methods, Bayesian fusion, Signal variance based fusion, Optimal fusion, Error variance based fusion and Extended Kalman Filter (EKF) based fusion are proposed and analyzed. The performances of the methods are analyzed in terms of Root Mean Square Error in Position (RMSPE) and Mean Absolute Error in Position (MAPE) for a wide range of measurement noise variances. It is concluded that EKF based fusion has the best error performance. Kalman Filter State-Vector Fusion (KF-SVF) which is a hierarchical fusion architecture, having first level of fusion with Kalman filter and second level with error variance based fusion method, is available in the literature. In this work it has been expanded to Extended Kalman Filter—State-Vector Fusion (EKF-SVF) with either error variance based fusion, signal variance based fusion or optimal information fusion as second level. All the three EKF-SVF methods have similar error characteristics, but EKF-SVF with signal variance based fusion, unlike the other two, provides less computational cost since it does not involve matrix inversion. While comparing EKF based fusion and EKF-SVF, EKF-SVF offers increased error minimization.