P-BN51 Subtotal cholecystectomy: risk factors and patient outcomes

Abstract

Abstract Background A subtotal cholecystectomy (SC) is indicated when a total cholecystectomy (TC) cannot be achieved without the risk of causing significant harm, the most feared complication being a bile duct injury. The aims of the present study were to identify patients at risk of SC, to compare the peri- and post-operative course between SC and TC and to compare outcomes between fenestrated and reconstituting subtypes. Methods All planned laparoscopic cholecystectomies across three surgical units over a population of 493,000 between 2015 and 2019 were considered. Data were collected retrospectively using electronic databases and included pre-operative, operative and post-operative data over a 100-day follow-up period. Variables associated with SC were identified using multivariate logistic regression. Outcomes following SC were compared with TC using univariate analysis, specifically chi-squared and Mann-Whitney U tests. The subtype of SC was documented and outcomes were compared between groups. Results The rate of SC was 3.4% (94/2768). Variables positively associated with SC included male sex (OR-2.33;p<0.001), age≥60 (OR-1.79;p=0.009), 2 previous admissions (OR-1.76;p=0.043), ≥3 previous admissions (OR-3.10;p=0.003), emergency cholecystectomy (OR-2.01;p=0.002); cholecystitis (OR-4.92;p<0.001) and pre-operative ERCP (OR-2.23;p<0.002). Patients with SC versus TC were more likely to suffer intra-operative complications (RR-13.1;p<0.001), post-operative complication (RR-6.7;p<0.001), require post-operative imaging/intervention (RR-4.0;p<0.001) and be re-admitted (RR-4.2; p < 0.001). The rate of bile duct injury was 0% in SC patients. The rate of post-operative bile leak was higher where the cystic duct was left open versus closed (RR-2.9;p=0.03) and in fenestrating SC versus reconstituting SC (35.7% versus 0%;p=0.002). Drain duration was reduced in reconstituting SC (p < 0.001). Conclusions The risk of SC can be explained by a number of patient specific factors and the risk should be emphasized in these patients during the consent process and should influence surgical decision making. The morbidity following a subtotal cholecystectomy is markedly higher than that of a total cholecystectomy but can be performed without significant risk of bile duct injury. Reconstituting SC and closure of the cystic duct reduces rates of post-operative bile leaks and duration of drains.