Oviposition preference maximizes larval survival in the grass-feeding butterfly Melanitis leda (Lepidoptera: Nymphalidae)

Abstract

Phytophagous insects may be expected to prefer host-plant species on which their larvae perform best, but this has rarely been explored in grass-feeding butterflies. We explored links between oviposition preferences, larval food preferences, and performance (larval survival and development time, pupal mass, and adult longevity) on 18 species of grass in the common evening brown, Melanitis leda L. (Nymphalidae: Melanitini), a tropical butterfly that has been recorded from a large number of species of grass. Melanitis leda oviposited on all of the grass species offered in choice experiments, and larvae were able to develop to the adult stage on almost all of them. Oviposition preferences were for species of plants on which larval survival was higher, but were not correlated with larval development. The mother's choice of host plant appeared to affect performance of the resulting adults as large butterflies had longer life spans. Ovipositing females appeared to adjust clutch size and position of their eggs on a plant depending on plant traits. Larval survival was only marginally correlated with larval growth rate on the different species of plants. Larvae showed host-plant preferences that were not correlated with adult oviposition preferences, larval survival, or larval growth. Overall, while M. leda can utilize a large number of species of grass, it shows marked oviposition preferences. Apparent fine-tuning of clutch size and positioning of eggs on plants with different traits might be another adaptation associated with using a large number of species of plants. We conclude that this grass feeding butterfly selects oviposition sites that maximize the chances of their larvae surviving.