Orthodontically induced root resorption: A critical analysis of finite element studies’ input and output

Abstract

Orthodontically induced inflammatory root resorption (OIIRR) constitutes an undesirable risk connected to orthodontic treatment. Finite element analysis (FEA) is a powerful tool to study the risk of OIIRR. However, its efficiency in predicting OIIRR depends on the insertion of the correct inputs and the selection of an output coherent with the clinical failure mechanism. By combining a systematic review with a 3-dimensional FEA, this article discusses which are the implications of using certain periodontal ligament (PDL) properties (linear and nonlinear models) and failure criteria. Six orthodontic loading regimes were simulated in a maxillary premolar: pure intrusion, buccal tipping, and their combination applied with either a light (25cN) or a heavy (225cN) force. Three stress parameters in the PDL were compared: von Mises stress, minimum principal stress, and hydrostatic stress (σH). The comparison between linear and nonlinear models showed notable differences in stress distribution patterns and magnitudes. For the nonlinear PDL, none of the light-force models reached the critical compressive hydrostatic stress of 4.7kPa, whereas all the heavy-force models reached it. In addition, the regions of critical compressive σH matched with the regions with resorption craters in clinical studies. In linear models, the σH critical value of 4.7kPa was reached even in the light-force scenario. Only compressive hydrostatic stress in PDL satisfied the requirements to be used as an FEA indicator of OIIRR. However, the requirements were satisfied only when a nonlinear PDL model was considered.