Organ-based tube current modulation versus spectral shaping via tin prefiltration: What does bismuth breast shielding add in low-dose lung CT?

Abstract

PurposeSince organ-based tube current modulation (OBTCM) and tin prefiltration are limited on their own in lowering the dose of lung CT examinations, this experimental study was designed to investigate whether combinations with anterior patient shielding can increase the dose reduction potential. Material and methodsThree pairs of scan protocols without/with breast shield (P1/P2: standard 120kVp, P3/P4: OBTCM at 100 kVp, P5/P6: Sn 100 kVp) were employed for radiation exposure and image quality comparisons on an anthropomorphic Alderson-Rando phantom. Equivalent doses were measured in eleven sites via thermoluminescent dosimetry and the effective dose was obtained by summation of the weighted organ doses. Dose-weighted contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRD) were calculated and four radiologists independently assessed the quality of images generated with each protocol. ResultsWhile no significant difference was determined between standard and OBTCM protocols regardless of breast shield (p ≥ 0.068), equivalent doses with spectral shaping were substantially lower (p ≤ 0.003). The highest effective dose was ascertained for standard scans (P1/P2: 7.3/6.8 mSv) with a dose reduction of 8.0 % via breast shielding. The use of a bismuth shield was more beneficial in OBTCM (P3/P4: 6.6/5.3 mSv) and spectral shaping (P5/P6: 0.7/0.6 mSv), reducing the effective dose by 19.8 % and 13.9 %, respectively. Subjective assessment favoured standard protocol P1 over tin prefiltration low-dose scans (p ≤ 0.032), however, no scan protocol entailed diagnostically insufficient image quality. ConclusionsWhereas breast shielding is particularly beneficial in combination with OBTCM, spectral shaping via tin prefiltration facilitates the most pronounced dose reduction in lung CT imaging with acceptable image quality.