Optimum management strategy for improving maize water productivity and partial factor productivity for nitrogen in China: A meta-analysis

Abstract

China’s agricultural production suffers significant constraints due to low water productivity (WP) and partial factor productivity for nitrogen (PFPN). The pivotal solution to enhance maize yield, WP, and PFPN is through optimizing field management practices. However, previous studies primarily focused on the effects of individual or coupled field management practices on maize yield, WP, or PFPN in an area or land mass, so it is necessary to conduct a comprehensive quantitative analysis of various field management practices on maize yield, WP, and PFPN at the national scale. In this study, we compiled 286 studies encompassing 6959 pairs of experimental data spanning from 1990 to 2023. Meta-analysis was conducted to observe the variations in maize yield, WP, and PFPN across diverse field management practices (straw returning, nitrogen fertilizer application, irrigation practice, and tillage practice) on a national scale. The results showed that nitrogen fertilizer application (215 kg N ha−1) was the most effective in enhancing maize yield and WP by 68.1 % and 54.8 %, respectively. Additionally, irrigation had the most substantial impact on PFPN, enhancing 16.8 %. Straw mulching, application of slow and controlled release fertilizers, drip irrigation, and subsoiling were identified as the most effective practices in increasing maize yield, WP, and PFPN by Random forest model. Maize straw returning could reduce nitrogen fertilizer application by 20 kg ha−1, while increasing WP and PFPN by 4.2 % and 11.6 %, respectively. Moreover, straw returning could reduce water consumption by 23–60 mm, while increasing WP and PFPN by 2.9 % and 6.8 %, respectively. These findings can provide a reference for the formulation of comprehensive management strategies for sustainable maize production in China and globally.