Opening windows into the mind: mothers’ preferences for mental state explanations and children’s theory of mind

Abstract

A new questionnaire, the Maternal Mental State Input Inventory (MMSII) was created to measure mothers’ preferences for introducing and elaborating on mental states in conversation with their young children. In two studies, the questionnaire was given to mothers of young children, and the children’s theory of mind (ToM) development was assessed with standard tasks. In both studies, the questionnaire exhibited good internal reliability, and significant correlations emerged between mothers’ self-reported preferences for elaborated, explanatory talk about the mental states and children’s theory of mind performance. Further, mothers’ conversational preferences, as measured by the MMSII, were the best predictors of children’s theory of mind development when relevant control variables were included in the analyses. These results converge with naturalistic observational research that has demonstrated links between mothers’ conversational styles and their children’s theory of mind. They go further in suggesting that mothers’ tendencies toward elaborated, explanatory talk about a range of mental states is particularly beneficial to children’s theory of mind development.