One is Good, but are Two Really Better? Outcomes for Dual versus Individual Attendees in a Behavioral Parent-Training Program for Caregivers of Young Children

Abstract

Listen

Translate article

ABSTRACT Background The Helping Our Toddlers, Developing Our Children’s Skills (HOT DOCS) BPMT program utilizes positive behavior support principles to help caregivers of children birth-5 years address early childhood disruptive behaviors and common developmental challenges experienced by many young children. Objective The present study examined whether there were differences in child outcomes, attendance rates, homework completion rates, levels of caregiver stress, and treatment satisfaction for individual versus dual caregiver participation in the HOT DOCS BPMT. Method Using a quasi-experimental design, caregivers of children ages 0–5 years were assigned to two non-equivalent groups: individual attendee (n = 141) and dual attendee (n = 123). Independent samples t-tests were utilized to compare means between individual and dual attendee groups for number of sessions attended and homework completion. Paired samples t-tests were calculated to compare means between individual and dual attendee groups on HOT DOCS program outcomes, including child behavior, parenting stress, and treatment satisfaction. Results There were no significant differences in outcomes between individual and dual attendee groups. Child behavior outcomes, parenting stress, treatment satisfaction, attendance, and homework completion were similar across both groups. Conclusions Individual caregiver engagement in the HOT DOCS BPMT program might be sufficiently potent to result in desirable outcomes. Future directions should include examining family structure and treatment modality on BPMT outcomes, maintenance of intervention gains, and perceived child behavior outcomes of BPMT non-attending caregivers.