On the origin of isolated olivine grains in type 2 carbonaceous chondrites

Abstract

The origin of olivine grains isolated in the matrix of C2 carbonaceous chondrites is an important problem. If these grains are condensates from a solar nebular gas, they contain compositional, isotopic and physical features that further elucidate that process. If, however, they are grains released by the breakup of chondrules, then many important condensation features have been lost during the melting that took place to form chondrules. In evaluating these two possibilities, care must be taken to determine which inclusions in C2 meteorites are actual chondrules and which are aggregates of grains that have never undergone melting. The two main types of aggregates, pyroxene-rich and pyroxene-poor, are forty to fifty times more abundant than chondrules. Four scenarios are presented to account for the kinds of aggregates and isolated grains seen in the Murchison C2 meteorite. An analysis of these scenarios is made in light of olivine crystal morphology, comparison of composition of glass inclusions inside olivine grains with interstitial glass in true chondrules and size distributions of olivines, isolated, in aggregates and in chondrules. It is concluded that no scenario that includes a chondrule-making step can account for the observed population of isolated olivine grains. An origin by direct condensation, partial comminution, aggregation and accretion best accounts for the sizes and morphological features observed.