Object labeling activates young children’s scale errors at an early stage of verb vocabulary growth

Abstract

Scale errors are intriguing developmental phenomena in which young children attempt to perform impossible object-specific actions toward miniature-sized objects. Of several related cognitive abilities, lexical development during toddlerhood enhances scale error production by making objects’ semantic representations dominant over perceptual information. To directly address the effect of activated semantic representations on scale errors, we examined whether and when object labeling affected scale errors. Toddlers aged 18 to 30 months (N = 72) performed a body-based scale error task twice: in one session with specific object labels provided (e.g., “chair”) and in the other session with general pronouns provided (e.g., “this”). Using different developmental indices, including chronological age and productive vocabulary size of nouns, verbs, and adjectives, the enhancement effect of object labeling was detected only for children whose verb vocabulary size was classified into the medium group (3–26 words). Moreover, verb vocabulary size was determined to be the best predictor of scale error production among the candidate developmental indices. We also found that toddlers produced more scale errors in the first session that they performed the task compared with the second session. In addition to revealing that careful control of relevant factors (e.g., developmental indices, labeling, task repetition) is required for scale error research, this study sheds light on the relevance of verb vocabulary on scale errors.