Nondifferentiable errors in beta-compliance integrated logistic models: numerical results

Abstract

In dose-response models, there are cases where only a portion of the administered dose may have an effect. This results in a stochastic compliance of the administered dose. In a previous paper (Chen-Mok and Sen, 1999), we developed suitable adjustments for compliance in the logistic model under the assumption of nondifferential measurement error. These compliance-adjusted models were categorized into three types: (i) Low (or near zero) dose levels, (ii) moderate dose levels, and (iii) high dose levels. In this paper, we analyze a set of data on the atomic bomb survivors of Japan to illustrate the use of the proposed methods. In addition, we examine the performance of these methods under different conditions based on a simulation study. Among all three cases, the adjustments proposed for the moderate dose case do not seem to work adequately. Both bias and variance are larger when using the adjusted model in comparison with the unadjusted model. The adjustments for the low dose case seem to work in reducing the bias in the estimation of the parameters under all types of compliance distributions. The MSEs, however, are larger under some of the compliance distribution considered. Finally, the results of this simulation study show that the adjustments for the high dose case are successful in achieving both a reduction in bias as well as a reduction in MSE, hence the overall efficiency of the estimation is improved.