Nicotine dependence among young adults: Comparing exclusive ENDS users to exclusive cigarette smokers

Abstract

PurposeNo studies of young adults have compared symptoms of nicotine dependence among exclusive past 30-day (P30D) ENDS users versus exclusive P30D cigarette smokers. MethodsParticipants at Wave 14 (Fall 2021) of The Texas Adolescent and Tobacco Marketing Surveillance System (TATAMS) (n = 2,341; mean age = 20.95 years old) who reported P30D exclusive ENDS use (n = 212) and P30D exclusive cigarette smoking (n = 46). Symptoms of nicotine dependence were measured with the Hooked On Nicotine Checklist (the 10-item HONC scale). An independent samples t-test compared average HONC scores between groups, and a Pearson (or Fisher’s Exact) Chi-Square (X2) test compared the prevalence of symptom(s) between groups. ResultsThe average HONC score was significantly higher for exclusive P30D ENDS users than exclusive P30D cigarette smokers (3.51 vs. 1.91, p ≤ 0.001). Compared to exclusive P30D cigarette smokers, a significantly higher proportion of exclusive P30D ENDS users reported having felt addicted (45.28% vs. 15.22%, p ≤ 0.001), having strong cravings (50.00% vs. 28.26%, p = 0.007), difficulty not using in prohibited places (i.e., school or work) (24.06% vs. 4.35%, p = 0.002), difficulty concentrating (21.23% vs. 6.52%, p = 0.021), and feeling nervous, restless, or anxious (28.77% vs. 10.87%, p = 0.012). ConclusionsSymptoms of nicotine dependence were elevated among young adults who were exclusive P30D users of ENDS relative to exclusive P30D cigarette smokers.