Nephron sparing surgery outcomes in Wilms' tumor: is it ready for primetime?

Abstract

Radical nephrectomy is the gold standard in Wilms tumor (WT) treatment and is combined with adjuvant treatment in early stage disease or performed after neo adjuvant therapy in advanced disease. With the development of novel adjuvant and neoadjuvant therapeutic strategies, there is increasing interest in organ preserving procedures in several adult malignancies. Potential long-term complications of living with a single kidney include hyperfiltration syndrome, hypertension, and fluid retention. If NSS (Nephron Sparing Surgery) were to be adopted for the treatment of WT it would be necessary to preserve the gains in Overall Survival (OS) seen with current treatment protocols. With this in mind we undertook a study of outcomes of NSS performed in the USA using a large population-based registry. We retrospectively queried the SEER Research Plus 18-registries Database 2010-2018 for patients 18years old or younger with Wilms tumor as determined by ICD-O-3 code 8960. Clinical and demographic data was extracted, and statistical analysis was performed in GraphPad PRISM 9 with bivariate analysis and log-rank analysis to determine survival. 1087 patients with Wilms tumor were identified. 73 (6.72%) underwent nephron-sparing surgery. The final cohort consisted of 45 patients (64%) who underwent unilateral NSS and 25 patients (36%) who underwent bilateral NSS. Three were excluded from analysis due to non-renal origin of tumor. Mean age was 3.214years (std dev 3.807). Demographics were similar between the groups, apart from younger age associated with bilateral tumor (p = 0.0441). No differences were found between radiation use (p = 0.4280), chemotherapy use (p = 0.5479), tumor size (p = 0.2186), positive regional lymph nodes (p = 0.707). Log-rank analysis demonstrated that cancer-specific survival was not significantly different between unilateral and bilateral NSS or radical nephrectomy (p = 0.4539). NSS may preserve renal function long-term, an important consideration in the pediatric population. Prospective study is necessary to select the appropriate patient subsets who may benefit from NSS in WT.