Negative association between chickpea response to competition and crop yield: Phenotypic and genetic analysis

Abstract

Donald’s ideotype and empirical evidence in cereal and oilseed crops indicate high yield is associated with less competitive plants. In this study we grew 20 chickpea lines in six environments to investigate the association between yield and intra-specific competitive ability and its genetic underpinnings using Fst genome scan based on whole genome resequencing data. We measured yield and its components and calculated response to competition (RC) as the ratio between the trait in outer rows (relaxed competition) and the trait in inner rows (higher competition). Crop yield correlated negatively with RC for yield, biomass, harvest index, seed number, and pod number. Fst genome scan revealed 14 genomic regions under selection for response to competition of yield, seed number or biomass, and 6 genomic regions under selection for yield in inner or outer canopy rows. Candidate genes in these regions include members of the nitrate-transporter 1 family, patatin and hormone-related genes. The top genomic regions found to be under selection for yield in inner rows and outer rows did not coincide. This genetic architecture provides a mechanistic basis for the observation that phenotypes that are adequate for relaxed competition often perform poorly in dense stands.