Mycelial interactions in Sclerotinia sclerotiorum

Abstract

Mycelial interactions were examined among 35 isolates of Sclerotinia sclerotiorum and two Asian species, Sclerotinia asari and an unnamed, Japanese species. Pairings were scored as compatible when strains merged to form one colony and incompatible when strains grew to form two distinct colonies. Incompatible mycelial pairings resulted in an interaction zone in which a distinct reaction line and abundant aerial mycelium or thin mycelium were observed with some variation among replicates. All pairings of a strain with itself were compatible. Of the 31 strains of S. sclerotiorum tested, 21 were mycelially incompatible with all others. Among the remaining 10 strains of S. sclerotiorum, there were four mycelial compatibility groups consisting of two or three strains each. Pairings of S. asari with all other strains resulted in a unique incompatible reaction, a mycelium-free interaction zone. Two of three strains of the Japanese species were intercompatible, but pairings of each of the three strains with all other strains were incompatible. Microscopically, mycelial interactions in pairings of strains were complex. Anastomosis between paired strains was not always observed. This may be due in part to the conversion of many hyphal tips, in both compatible and incompatible interactions, to sites of microconidiogenesis no longer capable of hyphal fusion. Incompatible pairings were followed by hyphal deterioration in one or both strains; hyphal deterioration was not observed in compatible interactions. Of the 31 strains tested, 4 strains of S. sclerotiorum produced apothecia. Pairings between single ascospore isolates within each strain were compatible, as were pairings with the parent isolate. Mycelial interactions of single ascospore isolates with other strains were identical to those of the parent isolate, indicating that the parent fruitbody was homozygous for any determinant(s) of mycelial incompatibility. The data from this study suggest that a high level of mycelial incompatibility exists among strains of S. sclerotiorum, comparable to levels of vegetative incompatibility reported in other ascomycetes, that the extent of mycelial incompatibility indicates that genetic heterogeneity exists within the species, and that mycelial compatibility/incompatibility reactions may be an effective way of categorizing intraspecific heterogeneity.