Multiobjective optimization of effect-directed planar chromatography as a promising tool for fast selection of polypotent natural products

Abstract

A new method for efficiently selecting polypotent natural products is proposed in this study. The method involves using effect-directed HPTLC data and multiobjective optimization algorithms to extract chromatographic signals from HPTLC bioassay images. Three different multiobjective optimization methods, namely Derringer's desirability approach, Technique for order of preference by similarity to ideal solution (TOPSIS), and Sum of ranking differences (SRD), were applied to the chromatographic signals. In combination with jackknife cross-validation, Derringer's approach and TOPSIS demonstrated high similarity in finding the best (most polypotent), next to the best, next to the worst, and worst (least polypotent) extracts, while the SRD resulted in slightly different outcomes.Furthermore, a new method for identifying the chromatographic features that characterize the most polypotent extracts was proposed. This method is based on partial least square regression (PLS) and can be used in combination with HPTLC-chemical fingerprints to predict the desirability of new extracts. The resulting PLS models demonstrated high statistical performance with determination coefficients ranging from R2 = 0.885 in the case of Derringer's desirability, to 0.986 for TOPSIS. However, the PLS modeling of SRD values was not successful.