Molecular genetic diagnostics for inherited retinal dystrophies in the clinical setting

Abstract

ObjectiveTo evaluate the success of diagnostic genetic testing in inherited retinal dystrophy (IRD) patients in the clinical setting. DesignRetrospective cohort analysis. ParticipantsA total of 446 consecutive participants from diverse ethnic backgrounds living in western Canada. MethodsClinical information was collected from participants, including family history, and they underwent a full ophthalmic examination with chart review. Those with a suspected IRD were offered panel-based genetic testing of 351 genes between March 1, 2019, and February 28, 2022. The main outcome measure was effect of the genetic testing results on clinical diagnosis. ResultsGenetic testing established a conclusive molecular diagnosis in 249 of 446 cases (55.8%), a clearly negative result in 90 of 446 cases (20.1%), and an inconclusive diagnosis in 108 of 446 cases (24.2%). Conclusive disease-causing variants were identified in 69 genes, and the most commonly affected genes were ABCA4 (31 variants), USH2A (25 variants), and RPGR (19 variants). The inconclusive group included likely novel autosomal dominant variants or a pathogenic variant with a variant of uncertain significance in the same gene for a recessive phenotype. Notably, an inconclusive molecular genetic diagnosis was seen in as many as 47.3% of East Asian participants with an outer retinal dystrophy. ConclusionsThis study represents the largest review of molecular genetic testing in IRDs in Canada. That negative or inconclusive results obtained in approximately 45% of cases demonstrates that there is an important need for new research into molecular genetic causes of IRDs. This is particularly true in addressing the problem of interpreting a variant of uncertain significance in ethnic minorities.