Modeling transpiration using solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence and photochemical reflectance index synergistically in a closed-canopy winter wheat ecosystem

Abstract

The joint use of solar-induced chlorophyll fluorescence (SIF) and the photochemical reflectance index (PRI) has been shown to improve gross primary productivity (GPP) estimation across various plant functional types. However, the utility of PRI in combination with SIF for transpiration (T) estimation has not yet been explored. Additionally, current SIF-driven transpiration models including linear models, semi-mechanical models (combination of canopy conductance, gC, derived from a SIF and vapor pressure deficit, VPD, driven linear model with the Penman-Monteith model), and hybrid models (combination of gC derived from a SIF and VPD driven machine learning model with the Penman-Monteith model) have rarely been mutually assessed. Based on concurrent remotely sensed SIF and PRI, and eddy covariance flux measurements during one growing season for a winter wheat ecosystem in northern China, we investigated the mediating effect of PRI on SIF-driven T estimation under different VPD conditions and compared the performance of linear, semi-mechanical, and hybrid models in estimating T. Our results showed that the mediating effect of PRI on T described in the SIF-driven linear, semi-mechanistic, and hybrid models was significant under high VPD conditions rather than under low VPD conditions. Specifically, based on T partitioned using an underlying water use efficiency method as a benchmark, the root mean square error (RMSE) value of the PRI-mediated linear, semi-mechanistic, and hybrid models was 28.01 W/m2, 22.25 W/m2, and 28.71 W/m2 lower, respectively, than those of the corresponding models without PRI when VPD was >1.5 kPa. Based on T partitioned using a transpiration estimation algorithm as a benchmark, these three models also exhibited a significant reduction in RMSE under high VPD conditions after considering PRI. The main rationale behind the PRI improvement is that PRI can track photosynthetic dynamics under high VPD conditions. Based on the simulation results of the Soil-Canopy-Observation of Photosynthesis and Energy fluxes (SCOPE) model, PRI can serve as an indicator for non-photochemical quenching (NPQ) within this ecosystem. Consequently, PRI can enhance the capability of SIF to characterize the energy dissipation of photosynthetically active radiation and help SIF to yield more accurate information on GPP and gc under high VPD conditions. Finally, the order of model performance in estimating T was generally hybrid model > semi-mechanistic model > linear model. Our findings show the effectiveness of PRI for improving SIF-driven transpiration estimation under high VPD conditions and provide a new hybrid model for estimating T from SIF.