Modeling the cost-effectiveness of stormwater best management practices in an urban watershed in Las Vegas Valley

Abstract

The Las Vegas Valley is one of the fastest growing urban areas in the United States. Any future urbanization and climate change, especially if the climate becomes wetter and there are more intense and frequent storm events, will undoubtedly cause excessive urban stormwater runoff and exacerbate flooding in the Valley. Stormwater management is therefore one of the key challenges to the local government. The main goal of this study was to ascertain the utility of Best management Practices (BMPs) in mitigating stormwater runoff in the Duck Creek watershed in the Las Vegas Valley. The cost-effectiveness of different BMPs were also compared so as to determine the best BMP arrangement under the current and future climate and land use change conditions. By applying SUSTAIN (System for Urban Stormwater Treatment and Analysis INtegration) as a comprehensive GIS-based modeling and decision support system in the BMP analyses, modeling results show that although the installation of the existing three detention basins in the watershed can provide a 9% flow reduction, these three detention basins alone will not be adequate in the future with the impending changes in climate and land use. To alleviate the potential problems of water resources, SUSTAIN was further used to determine the number of additional BMPs required, the optimal types of BMPs (such as, detention and infiltration BMPs), and their locations in reducing storm runoff in the watershed under the future land-use and climate regimes. By comparing the performances of five potential BMP implementation scenarios, it was found that a mixed implementation of one additional detention BMP and one infiltration BMP to the existing detention BMPs in the downstream area of the watershed would be the most cost-effective stormwater runoff control solution in face of future urbanization and climate change. Depending on the locations of the new detention and infiltration BMPs, surface flow, even without BMP retrofit options, could be reduced by 27–31%. The cost for such installations would range from $1,141,000 to $1,319,000. This information may be useful to local planners and water resource managers in their efforts to develop alternative stormwater management plans in the arid Southwest.