Modeling of high-speed, methane–air, turbulent combustion, Part I: One-dimensional turbulence modeling with comparison to DNS

Abstract

The ability of the one-dimensional turbulence (ODT) model to serve as a surrogate direct numerical simulation (DNS) is assessed for highly turbulent flames. The ODT model is applied to freely propagating premixed methane–air flames at Karlovitz numbers 10, 102, 103, and 104, and results are compared with DNS. The ODT model solves the conservation equations for momentum, energy, and species on a one-dimensional domain, which corresponds to a streamwise line of sight spanning the DNS domain. The effects of turbulent advection are modeled via a stochastic process, in which the Kolmogorov and reactive length and time scales are explicitly resolved. Molecular transport and chemical kinetics are concurrently advanced in time. Both the ODT and DNS simulations use a 21-species skeletal chemical model for methane combustion. The accuracy of the ODT model is assessed by comparing its predictions of several key characteristics of the flames for each Karlovitz number tested, including the turbulent flame speed and width and the joint probability density functions (jPDFs) of major and selected minor species as well as the heat release rate conditioned on temperature with the results of DNS under comparable conditions. The ODT model is shown to yield qualitative and quantitative agreement with the DNS data for most of the above flame characteristics. Discrepancies are observed primarily for the jPDFs of several minor species examined. Overall, the ODT approach is shown to be an effective surrogate of DNS, potentially useful for guiding chemical reaction model reduction and for assessing the sensitivities of the flame structure and the burning rate to chemistry under highly turbulent conditions.Novelty and Significance:The direct numerical simulations (DNS) of premixed turbulent methane–air flames presented in this work span a uniquely wide range of turbulent intensities, from relatively modest corresponding to Karlovitz number Ka=10 to ultra-high intensities at Ka=104. This represents virtually the entire range of turbulent intensities that could be encountered in any realistic situation. This is also the first time that such a wide range of conditions is probed for methane in high-fidelity, fully resolved simulations, which use a fully compressible set of flow equations. The one-dimensional turbulence (ODT) model utilizes the same forcing that is present in the DNS enabling a direct comparison between the ODT and DNS. The results show that ODT captures the key features of the DNS results. ODT is shown to be an effective surrogate for DNS and may be useful in guiding chemical reaction model reduction, where many simulations are required.