Mixed application of controlled-release urea and normal urea can improve crop productivity and reduce the carbon footprint under straw return in winter wheat-summer maize cropping system

Abstract

An important goal of sustainable agriculture is reducing the environmental risk while also ensuring food security. The mixed application of controlled-release urea and normal urea (CRUNU) is a potential nitrogen (N) management strategy for achieving this goal. However, few studies have focused on whether optimizing the N application rate of CRUNU can balance crop yield and greenhouse gas emissions, especially when straw is returned. Thus, we conducted a five-year field experiment in a winter wheat–summer maize planting system in Northwest China to determine the effects of different N fertilizer types (NU: normal urea; CRUNU) and N application levels (low N, 135 kg ha–1; medium N, 180 kg ha–1; high N, 225 kg ha–1) with straw return on the crop yield and stability, N fertilizer partial factor productivity (NFPF), and soil organic carbon (SOC). Life cycle assessment was also conducted to quantify the GHG emissions from farmland and carbon footprint (CF). Compared with NU, CRUNU improved the winter wheat and summer maize grain yield, biomass, and NFPF at all three N application levels. The crop grain yields increased significantly as the N application level increased under NU, but the crop grain yields did not differ significantly between the medium and high N application levels under CRUNU (P > 0.05). The SOC contents increased as the duration of straw return increased. Compared with NU, CRUNU significantly increased the SOC content, and correlation analysis showed that this increase was related to the increased amount of returned straw. Compared with NU, CRUNU increased the GHG emissions in the production process but reduced the GHG emissions in the application process, as well as increasing soil CO2 fixation to ultimately reduce the total GHG emissions. CRUNU increased the crop grain yield while also reducing the total GHG emissions, and thus the CF decreased significantly by 14.53–23.03% compared with NU, especially at the medium N application level. Therefore, this comprehensive analysis of the crop productivity and GHG emissions indicates that CRUNU combined with an appropriate N application level can be used as a nitrogen fertilizer management strategy for sustainable winter wheat–summer maize cropping in Northwest China.