Mechanical overload and skeletal muscle fiber hyperplasia: a meta-analysis.

Abstract

With use of the meta-analytic approach, the purpose of this study was to examine the effects of mechanical overload on skeletal muscle fiber number in animals. A total of 17 studies yielding 37 data points and 360 subjects met the initial criteria: 1) "basic" research studies published in journals, 2) animals (no humans) as subjects, 3) control group included, 4) some type of mechanical overload (stretch, exercise, or compensatory hypertrophy) used to induce changes in muscle fiber number, and 5) sufficient data to accurately calculate percent changes in muscle fiber number. Across all designs and categories, statistically significant increases were found for muscle fiber number [15.00 +/- 19.60% (SD), 95% confidence interval = 8.65-21.53], muscle fiber area (31.60 +/- 44.30%, 95% confidence interval = 16.83-46.37), and muscle mass (90.50 +/- 86.50%, 95% confidence interval = 61.59-119.34). When partitioned according to the fiber-counting technique, larger increases in muscle fiber number were found by using the histological vs. nitric acid digestion method (histological = 20.70%, nitric acid digestion = 11.10%; P = 0.14). Increases in fiber number partitioned according to species were greatest among those groups that used an avian vs. mammalian model (avian = 20.95%, mammalian = 7.97%; P = 0.07). Stretch overload yielded larger increases in muscle fiber number than did exercise and compensatory hypertrophy (stretch = 20.95%, exercise = 11.59%, compensatory hypertrophy = 5.44%; P = 0.06). No significant differences between changes in fiber number were found when data were partitioned according to type of control (intra-animal = 15.20%, between animal = 13.90%; P = 0.82) or fiber arrangement of muscle (parallel = 15.80%, pennate = 11.60%; P = 0.61). The results of this study suggest that in several animal species certain forms of mechanical overload increase muscle fiber number.